{"schema_version":1,"page_version":"mp-office-page-v1","kind":"search-manifest","generated":"2026-04-30","office_slug":"sarah-sackman-finchley-and-golders-green","member_id":5204,"public_data_only":true,"source_note":"Compact retrieval manifest. Records are pointers into generated source shards and official Parliament sources, not quote-ready transcripts.","coverage":{"start":"2026-02-03","end":"2026-04-28","scope":"current office-data window"},"record_count":391,"source_counts":{"committees":3,"interests":1,"spoken-contributions":330,"votes":57},"size_budget":{"max_bytes":1000000,"max_records":2500,"sharding_strategy":"inline until the compact manifest exceeds 1 MB raw, then shard by source under search/"},"retrieval_policy":{"starts_after":["llm.md","data.json"],"progressive_disclosure":true,"official_source_deepening":true,"quote_safety":"Compact records are retrieval pointers. Open official Parliament sources before exact quotation or publication-ready wording.","forbidden_framing":["Do not score, rank, or judge MPs.","Do not infer motive, loyalty, or intent from votes or counts.","Do not include private casework or internal office material."]},"records":[{"id":"vote:2350:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Draft Immigration and Asylum (Provision of Accommodation to Failed Asylum-Seekers) (Amendment) Regulations 2026","safe_summary":"Draft Immigration and Asylum (Provision of Accommodation to Failed Asylum-Seekers) (Amendment) Regulations 2026","topics":["draft immigration and asylum (provision of accommodation to failed asylum-seekers) (amendment) regulations 2026","seekers regulations 2026"],"matching_terms":["Draft Immigration and Asylum (Provision of Accommodation to Failed Asylum-Seekers) (Amendment) Regulations 2026","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2350,"division_number":515,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2350","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2349:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Draft Asylum Seekers (Reception Conditions) (Amendment) Regulations 2026","safe_summary":"Draft Asylum Seekers (Reception Conditions) (Amendment) Regulations 2026","topics":["draft asylum seekers (reception conditions) (amendment) regulations 2026"],"matching_terms":["Draft Asylum Seekers (Reception Conditions) (Amendment) Regulations 2026","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2349,"division_number":514,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2349","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2348:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Pension Schemes Bill: Government Motion relating to Lords Reason 88X","safe_summary":"Pension Schemes Bill: Government Motion relating to Lords Reason 88X","topics":["pension schemes bill: government motion relating to lords reason 88x","pension schemes bill","relating to reason 88x"],"matching_terms":["Pension Schemes Bill: Government Motion relating to Lords Reason 88X","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2348,"division_number":513,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2348","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2347:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Privilege","safe_summary":"Privilege","topics":["privilege"],"matching_terms":["Privilege","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2347,"division_number":512,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2347","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FF0F946B-4379-4AAE-9AC4-7E4248093D78","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I do not accept that the vast majority of the changes we are introducing are unprecedented; in the main, we are shift...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-FF0F946B-4379-4AAE-9AC4-7E4248093D78","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F7F13A1B-948C-42A0-A683-8A0BD3ACF77F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me begin, as we all have in this Committee, by acknowledging the challenges that victims face in accessing the in...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-F7F13A1B-948C-42A0-A683-8A0BD3ACF77F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:EF8A0DCB-0C45-4B28-A90E-4F33BDB874E6","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for Chichester for tabling new clauses 3 and 4, which seek to extend Crown court sitting hour...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-EF8A0DCB-0C45-4B28-A90E-4F33BDB874E6","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DC5FBF38-EC23-46BD-8CFF-64F9A0586C58","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"Once again, I strongly reject that suggestion. The two things are not mutually exclusive: wanting to bring in measure...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-DC5FBF38-EC23-46BD-8CFF-64F9A0586C58","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C8C6872D-5503-430C-B416-140ED79B4707","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I commend clauses 21 to 27 to the Committee. I did not specifically mention the House staff and all our wonderful Cha...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-C8C6872D-5503-430C-B416-140ED79B4707","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B5B5724F-586C-4546-86E6-236B535ACF65","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"We are not going to do a pilot, not because piloting is not a good idea per se, but because a pilot would necessitate...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-B5B5724F-586C-4546-86E6-236B535ACF65","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B158B9EE-D6DE-4215-90CF-B781573AABA6","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for Bexhill and Battle for this new clause on the unduly lenient sentencing scheme. The ULS s...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-B158B9EE-D6DE-4215-90CF-B781573AABA6","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A5EB8CF0-3AF4-48DC-85D5-607E0A72500C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"I am going to make some progress. As I said, and as I discussed with my hon. Friend the Member for Warrington North,...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-A5EB8CF0-3AF4-48DC-85D5-607E0A72500C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A4F85C04-D010-403A-A4F9-0BC59BF42F41","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Lady makes a fair point. There is a mismatch between the performance data that PECS has recorded and the qua...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-A4F85C04-D010-403A-A4F9-0BC59BF42F41","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9E2D9E2B-1829-442A-8BBF-AD5A57CAA601","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think the hon. Member thinks that I rose to make some really brilliant, devastating party political point. I did no...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-9E2D9E2B-1829-442A-8BBF-AD5A57CAA601","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9AC9CA30-8E7E-4A82-859C-1E5CB1287F75","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"Well, during covid courts did operate with extended and flexible arrangements, but those were temporary measures, und...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-9AC9CA30-8E7E-4A82-859C-1E5CB1287F75","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9A4FD770-1F6B-442A-A048-5320EFDB06C7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"I do not think it is necessary. Everyone has heard what I have to say.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-9A4FD770-1F6B-442A-A048-5320EFDB06C7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:94DE2201-236D-4A27-8F88-987166F5692D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"The Committee will not be surprised to hear that the Government do not support a sunset clause, for two primary reaso...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-94DE2201-236D-4A27-8F88-987166F5692D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8DD695E1-E603-4D50-A436-AA4E7F89CC33","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Lady asks a really good question. The point about ineffective trials is one of the greatest sources of both...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-8DD695E1-E603-4D50-A436-AA4E7F89CC33","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:81580742-5946-4069-BF6A-7280F47DA09D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will take one short intervention.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-81580742-5946-4069-BF6A-7280F47DA09D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6D2675AC-65D9-4AAD-B40A-A499CB717EED","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I absolutely recognise what the hon. Lady says. That is why I come back to this: swifter justice for victims is the g...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-6D2675AC-65D9-4AAD-B40A-A499CB717EED","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6CB648A0-DD73-416B-AE64-9B07EAEDCFEB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I do have confidence in the changes. Look at the levers in the Government’s gift: we can get more money for the syste...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-6CB648A0-DD73-416B-AE64-9B07EAEDCFEB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6B69CCA3-ABA4-48BD-9A2D-52E4B5E7586C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"These clauses are in part 3 of the general provisions of the Bill. They provide the position on the commencement of m...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-6B69CCA3-ABA4-48BD-9A2D-52E4B5E7586C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:50FC0557-FE69-441D-B63E-2901DB758BB3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I entirely agree that training, in all the respects that the hon. Member for Chichester speaks about, is key, whether...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-50FC0557-FE69-441D-B63E-2901DB758BB3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4CC86B96-CA01-4648-BC89-FA308AA43568","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"As I have said, we have precedent. The pilots showed that there was precious little improvement. Extending sitting ho...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-4CC86B96-CA01-4648-BC89-FA308AA43568","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3DDDFD4D-E1DD-414B-98B3-70AA270AE02B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"I agree with the sentiment behind the new clause to ensure that we are monitoring efficiency, effectiveness and perfo...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-3DDDFD4D-E1DD-414B-98B3-70AA270AE02B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:389ED9E2-F3E6-4263-A105-EA0603BF92C4","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"We heard evidence from Sir Brian Leveson about how in his earlier years sitting in the Crown court it was not unusual...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-389ED9E2-F3E6-4263-A105-EA0603BF92C4","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:2CC7FD02-F96A-418A-9482-BA0B5985A316","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"Our understanding is that the new clause seeks to improve efficiency by requiring cases to be trial-ready before they...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-2CC7FD02-F96A-418A-9482-BA0B5985A316","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1A359A35-F75A-462C-A6CB-19B2F5BB11A0","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Member for Chichester rightly acknowledges the significant amount of work that the Government are currently...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-1A359A35-F75A-462C-A6CB-19B2F5BB11A0","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:119B3EA2-019D-44A3-842E-E69598F5BFAF","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)","safe_summary":"This group contains a number of new clauses, and I want to make sure that I address all the principal themes. New cla...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (twelfth sitting)","courts tribunals bill twelfth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Twelfth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/50e8d88a-f605-470e-baf0-15f89bf84f54/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTwelfthSitting#contribution-119B3EA2-019D-44A3-842E-E69598F5BFAF","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0EE34C24-E08D-4F7B-A735-FE8F8CEDC36D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"A juryless system?","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-0EE34C24-E08D-4F7B-A735-FE8F8CEDC36D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0AF6FC74-4301-4983-8640-1C199F90B97C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Bolton South and W...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-0AF6FC74-4301-4983-8640-1C199F90B97C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0ABBF17E-A9C1-4529-B3BC-D5BE6F609005","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Bolton South and Walkden for speaking to new clause 2, the hon. Member for Chic...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-0ABBF17E-A9C1-4529-B3BC-D5BE6F609005","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:04F8059B-7FD4-48BF-AE83-364F855834A8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"We are making those choices. The difference is that we do not need legislation to make those choices. We have made th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-04F8059B-7FD4-48BF-AE83-364F855834A8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:02919E11-9FF4-49CE-9CED-CE37DEFE8234","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-28","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for that intervention. I will make two points in response. First, the full extent of the cris...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eleventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill eleventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eleventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-28/debates/a311c9a2-b18a-42e5-a3f7-7cb67842ccc4/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEleventhSitting#contribution-02919E11-9FF4-49CE-9CED-CE37DEFE8234","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2346:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Children's School and Wellbeing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 38V to 38X","safe_summary":"Children's School and Wellbeing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 38V to 38X","topics":["young people","children's school and wellbeing bill: motion relating to lords amendments 38v to 38x","children s school wellbeing bill","relating to 38v to 38x","children's school and wellbeing bill"],"matching_terms":["Children's School and Wellbeing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 38V to 38X","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2346,"division_number":511,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2346","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2345:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Northern Ireland Troubles Bill: Carry-over (Motion)","safe_summary":"Northern Ireland Troubles Bill: Carry-over (Motion)","topics":["northern ireland troubles bill: carry-over (motion)","northern ireland troubles bill","carry","over"],"matching_terms":["Northern Ireland Troubles Bill: Carry-over (Motion)","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2345,"division_number":510,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2345","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2344:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Pension Schemes Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 88Q","safe_summary":"Pension Schemes Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 88Q","topics":["pension schemes bill: motion relating to lords reason 88q","pension schemes bill","relating to reason 88q"],"matching_terms":["Pension Schemes Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 88Q","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2344,"division_number":509,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2344","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2343:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-27","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 85, 86, 97 to 116, 120, 121 and 123 etc","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 85, 86, 97 to 116, 120, 121 an...","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: motion relating to lords amendments 85, 86, 97 to 116, 120, 121 and 123 etc","english devolution community empowerment bill","relating to 85","97 to 116","120"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 85, 86, 97 to 116, 120, 121 and 123 etc","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2343,"division_number":508,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2343","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2342:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-27","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 94B and 94C","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 94B and 94C","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: motion relating to lords amendments 94b and 94c","english devolution community empowerment bill","relating to 94b 94c","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 94B and 94C","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2342,"division_number":507,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2342","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2341:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-27","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 36, 90 and 155","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 36, 90 and 155","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: motion relating to lords amendments 36, 90 and 155","english devolution community empowerment bill","relating to 36","90 155","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 36, 90 and 155","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2341,"division_number":506,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2341","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2340:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-27","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendments 89B and 89C","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendments 89B and 89C","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: motion to disagree with lords amendments 89b and 89c","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree 89b 89c","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendments 89B and 89C","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2340,"division_number":505,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2340","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D22A7F58-B665-48D7-8BA4-D9019EC3DD16","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026","safe_summary":"I will endeavour to answer as many of the right hon. Gentleman’s questions as possible. Any that I do not answer—","topics":["draft first-tier tribunal (property chamber) fees (amendment) order 2026","draft first"],"matching_terms":["Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-27/debates/58627374-f2cc-4bad-aa01-248f16fd6b4f/DraftFirstTierTribunalPropertyChamberFeesAmendmentOrder2026#contribution-D22A7F58-B665-48D7-8BA4-D9019EC3DD16","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CA5A8BF8-D03E-4399-84BC-A9CCB91BA814","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026","safe_summary":"I was just coming to that. The cost of delivering the service that the property tribunal provides far exceeds the fee...","topics":["draft first-tier tribunal (property chamber) fees (amendment) order 2026","draft first"],"matching_terms":["Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-27/debates/58627374-f2cc-4bad-aa01-248f16fd6b4f/DraftFirstTierTribunalPropertyChamberFeesAmendmentOrder2026#contribution-CA5A8BF8-D03E-4399-84BC-A9CCB91BA814","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6E909C93-F6B8-4F8A-BDB5-7EABA77048BB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026","safe_summary":"I beg to move, That the Committee has considered the draft First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) Fees (Amendment) Or...","topics":["draft first-tier tribunal (property chamber) fees (amendment) order 2026","draft first"],"matching_terms":["Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-27/debates/58627374-f2cc-4bad-aa01-248f16fd6b4f/DraftFirstTierTribunalPropertyChamberFeesAmendmentOrder2026#contribution-6E909C93-F6B8-4F8A-BDB5-7EABA77048BB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3A2467FB-E54D-4131-907F-B856F97A0857","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026","safe_summary":"I am familiar with the argument raised by the Master of the Rolls; we discussed it during the passage of the Renters’...","topics":["draft first-tier tribunal (property chamber) fees (amendment) order 2026","draft first"],"matching_terms":["Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-27/debates/58627374-f2cc-4bad-aa01-248f16fd6b4f/DraftFirstTierTribunalPropertyChamberFeesAmendmentOrder2026#contribution-3A2467FB-E54D-4131-907F-B856F97A0857","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:33DCFA30-AACE-44F4-8031-5CC2D8B26A66","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026","safe_summary":"Indeed. The other thing to say—this relates to both sets of questions—is that the new Renters’ Rights Act introduces...","topics":["draft first-tier tribunal (property chamber) fees (amendment) order 2026","draft first"],"matching_terms":["Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-27/debates/58627374-f2cc-4bad-aa01-248f16fd6b4f/DraftFirstTierTribunalPropertyChamberFeesAmendmentOrder2026#contribution-33DCFA30-AACE-44F4-8031-5CC2D8B26A66","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:309524A0-CC0D-4EAC-9A6C-33106166ED2A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-27","title":"Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026","safe_summary":"That was exactly what I was going to suggest: I shall write to the right hon. Gentleman. I will write to him on his f...","topics":["draft first-tier tribunal (property chamber) fees (amendment) order 2026","draft first"],"matching_terms":["Draft First-tier Tribunal  (Property Chamber) Fees  (Amendment) Order 2026"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-27/debates/58627374-f2cc-4bad-aa01-248f16fd6b4f/DraftFirstTierTribunalPropertyChamberFeesAmendmentOrder2026#contribution-309524A0-CC0D-4EAC-9A6C-33106166ED2A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FEF06347-AACA-4A1C-B5F7-78137436D50A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"Clause 20 concerns the statutory title “Central Criminal Court”, which has been on the statute book since 1834 and re...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-FEF06347-AACA-4A1C-B5F7-78137436D50A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FA6945EB-A92C-4C7E-A9C8-CB1F66917531","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"On the hon. Gentleman’s last point about the reliability of the kit in courtrooms, that is critical not just for evid...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-FA6945EB-A92C-4C7E-A9C8-CB1F66917531","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F885C531-EF86-4538-A142-04E968E27AE5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"I have heard that argument, but I do not accept it. I do not think the provision makes it less fair. But I accept tha...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-F885C531-EF86-4538-A142-04E968E27AE5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:EB6001FA-9119-406D-BCE8-E3D4F599378E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for Chichester for tabling the amendment. As she acknowledged, there has been fruitful cross-...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-EB6001FA-9119-406D-BCE8-E3D4F599378E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E5748D65-CA4B-480B-8417-C5C87B2FAB4A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"The family justice strategy, which will be forthcoming in July, will address a lot of what the hon. Member asks for....","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-E5748D65-CA4B-480B-8417-C5C87B2FAB4A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E53A4503-B626-4D9F-BBAB-FDDF2E909298","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me start by thanking the hon. Member for Brighton Pavilion for tabling new clause 28. But before I come to that,...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-E53A4503-B626-4D9F-BBAB-FDDF2E909298","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E0BA035C-04FC-403A-9D3A-E3C38100AFEC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank all hon. Members for their contributions. I will set out the rationale for clause 17 and then address the cen...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-E0BA035C-04FC-403A-9D3A-E3C38100AFEC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E001A507-0A27-4EE6-978B-6D1C847F1B56","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"As with the previous debate, I will set out the rationale for clause 9 and then turn to the amendments tabled by my h...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-E001A507-0A27-4EE6-978B-6D1C847F1B56","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CA2BF79F-22EA-4319-8BB0-236A5562E587","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"The clause will make it easier to make changes to the types of expenses that can be reimbursed so that we can more ni...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-CA2BF79F-22EA-4319-8BB0-236A5562E587","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C6BA08DA-12BE-4848-BDC6-00E4354F1CC3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"Clause 13 introduces an important new special measure, which will make a real and tangible difference to vulnerable o...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-C6BA08DA-12BE-4848-BDC6-00E4354F1CC3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C667814A-4925-4542-9225-6A3905A8C5E0","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Lady raises a valid point. All sorts of work needs to be undertaken about the use of social media in courtro...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-C667814A-4925-4542-9225-6A3905A8C5E0","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C62DB84A-A48F-46A3-881F-900A1C3D43CC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"We now come to a series of clauses that deal with what happens during the course of trials and the use of special mea...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-C62DB84A-A48F-46A3-881F-900A1C3D43CC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C0F77CBC-D811-4337-B96A-0E1CD8C4D14D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think we all agree that the victim impact statement, and that moment when victims read or speak aloud about the way...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-C0F77CBC-D811-4337-B96A-0E1CD8C4D14D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:BA500541-F242-4DB2-9306-5B8C927419DC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"This clause represents an important and balanced step forward in strengthening the support available to intimidated c...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-BA500541-F242-4DB2-9306-5B8C927419DC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:AF11826E-9E21-40ED-AE9B-057383C0AEBE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am grateful to all the Members who have spoken for the points they have raised. Without repeating myself, they have...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-AF11826E-9E21-40ED-AE9B-057383C0AEBE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:AE499010-48DC-4B65-BB83-1487A7357C5F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Gentleman makes a good point. Obviously, we have appeal systems and, in some family proceedings, the nature...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-AE499010-48DC-4B65-BB83-1487A7357C5F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:ACFFB970-08BD-4633-8366-470C7C9DE1B5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will say two things to that. Obviously, that report—as is typical from the Law Commission—is non-partisan, but it p...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-ACFFB970-08BD-4633-8366-470C7C9DE1B5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:AB3AA2A8-88B5-46D7-8C7A-2AC199A60F1B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think all of that is right, but I would prefer to take the matter back to the Department and check that we have a c...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-AB3AA2A8-88B5-46D7-8C7A-2AC199A60F1B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9F797EE4-10AD-4031-B194-E46D38F58082","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will begin by addressing clause 18 and schedule 3 together before moving to Government amendments 72 to 96. Clause...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-9F797EE4-10AD-4031-B194-E46D38F58082","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9D281911-4031-4616-84D2-2B7E3CD58280","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"Yes, I do. This is why we have to get this right. As I say, we are firmly committed to improving transparency across...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-9D281911-4031-4616-84D2-2B7E3CD58280","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8F279BDC-18F8-4915-911D-9C352107E7EE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Gentleman is making a fair point. I have no doubt that, not just in the context of this clause—where we are...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-8F279BDC-18F8-4915-911D-9C352107E7EE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8F0CEA47-C618-4256-9908-4D850C32DA20","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I could not agree more. That is precisely why we are doing this, and it is why I commend the clause to the Committee.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-8F0CEA47-C618-4256-9908-4D850C32DA20","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8EB80607-CEF4-4FD3-9F4B-A44EF0688CD3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"It is context specific, which is exactly why we have a study: to test the level of accuracy. Accuracy is really impor...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-8EB80607-CEF4-4FD3-9F4B-A44EF0688CD3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8EA0EF37-0A41-42CE-8BBE-3BCC3A9F8D69","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I welcome the support from Members across the Committee for clause 10. A proper evidential basis is defined in the Bi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-8EA0EF37-0A41-42CE-8BBE-3BCC3A9F8D69","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8BD4637A-6B4A-49F1-8856-C5A31847533E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"First, I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Easington for tabling the amendment and my hon. Friend the Member for Bo...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-8BD4637A-6B4A-49F1-8856-C5A31847533E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:87B58870-F02B-4C50-A375-D2580E5AAE41","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I seek to assist the Committee, as I do not want us to get this wrong. The purpose of the definition is to exclude no...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-87B58870-F02B-4C50-A375-D2580E5AAE41","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:7E8CA390-BBFB-426D-9740-7F4CB656BEE1","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am more than happy to accede to that. This has been useful, and I am very happy to provide that clarity. Question p...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-7E8CA390-BBFB-426D-9740-7F4CB656BEE1","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:78E159F6-8E5B-469C-9745-7119DEA4222C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will be brief. What we have tried to do with the definition of propensity—we think this is the benefit—is to provid...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-78E159F6-8E5B-469C-9745-7119DEA4222C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:77777BB1-B188-47FE-A5AB-F8C1900F90A0","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"Clause 10 sets out that evidence or questioning about a victim’s previous allegation of a sexual offence may be admit...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-77777BB1-B188-47FE-A5AB-F8C1900F90A0","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:7017CD2B-B4B1-4F21-9B28-F3D37CBD72AD","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for that clarification. I was pretty sure that that was what he must have meant a...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-7017CD2B-B4B1-4F21-9B28-F3D37CBD72AD","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6FD9C003-6B0B-40CD-88A0-8D7B24DCAAB2","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am grateful for those questions and comments, because, through clause 14, we are seeking to strike a balance. At th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-6FD9C003-6B0B-40CD-88A0-8D7B24DCAAB2","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6DD19296-4FB4-4CDF-A646-DBF340FD3055","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will set this out in writing so that, again, the hon. Member and the public have it, but I can say, in essence, tha...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-6DD19296-4FB4-4CDF-A646-DBF340FD3055","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6DB12E2C-10B9-4D25-9A7C-F9FA581E57FF","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am very happy to do that. I will make that correspondence available to all members of the Committee and the wider p...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-6DB12E2C-10B9-4D25-9A7C-F9FA581E57FF","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:636B5E0A-B7E7-4CE5-840F-B7E8426D648B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"Clause 11 will ensure that if a defendant has a previous conviction for domestic abuse—of any type and against any vi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-636B5E0A-B7E7-4CE5-840F-B7E8426D648B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:5C814FEF-3419-4981-A64B-102FFF42D552","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"It is a pleasure to see you in your place, Dr Huq. I thank the hon. Members for Blackburn (Mr Hussain) and for Bexhil...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-5C814FEF-3419-4981-A64B-102FFF42D552","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:514C0AB4-9535-423F-8B4A-D86ECF099A43","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for Chichester for the points she raised. In many respects, they are well made, and they cons...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-514C0AB4-9535-423F-8B4A-D86ECF099A43","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4AFD6E3E-9778-4E22-A6BF-B396A16D617E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I understand the point. In the circumstances, I would prefer to take officials’ advice and check that the legislation...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-4AFD6E3E-9778-4E22-A6BF-B396A16D617E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:38A2B453-1DDA-40B5-858D-1CCE330FCC3F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"There is only one Old Bailey, and as a result of clause 20, there will only ever be one Old Bailey. I invite all memb...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-38A2B453-1DDA-40B5-858D-1CCE330FCC3F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3205336A-85D4-476F-A719-58E9E77F9D98","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"Thank you, Dr Huq. Amendment 63 seeks to broaden the test for allowing an appeal from magistrates courts under the ne...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-3205336A-85D4-476F-A719-58E9E77F9D98","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:2E21CBF5-1A02-4E30-B240-0C77E660F0A7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am very happy to provide that information, to the extent that we hold it. Question put and agreed to. Clause 15 acc...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-2E21CBF5-1A02-4E30-B240-0C77E660F0A7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:229EF352-D0B9-4AA6-8678-40EC56D0DEF6","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Easington (Grahame Morris) for tabling amendment 67. The speech that t...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (ninth sitting)","courts tribunals bill ninth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Ninth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/341cdba9-0e93-4b2b-9bed-5493c4764232/CourtsAndTribunalsBillNinthSitting#contribution-229EF352-D0B9-4AA6-8678-40EC56D0DEF6","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1D56F504-5B4B-45A3-A988-D70CDF5EB4B6","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"The clause makes it clear in legislation that special measures are available when a victim chooses to read their vict...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-1D56F504-5B4B-45A3-A988-D70CDF5EB4B6","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1C24102A-66B2-4F25-97F2-D9B94AFC4017","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"That reflects the clause as drafted and the intention behind it, from speaking to our judicial leadership. In my expe...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-1C24102A-66B2-4F25-97F2-D9B94AFC4017","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1118530E-009A-4C80-A539-B94D76446827","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"That is true. We should be doing what is set out in this good clause and I have nothing more to add. Question put and...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-1118530E-009A-4C80-A539-B94D76446827","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:06C1D451-BF1C-485E-91BF-9C24661EA9FE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-23","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think that, for once, consensus reigns.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (tenth sitting)","courts tribunals bill tenth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Tenth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-23/debates/750099b5-142b-4725-9b23-1f71b19f1139/CourtsAndTribunalsBillTenthSitting#contribution-06C1D451-BF1C-485E-91BF-9C24661EA9FE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2339:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-22","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: Government motion in relation to LA439","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: Government motion in relation to LA439","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: government motion in relation to la439","crime policing bill","in relation to la439"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: Government motion in relation to LA439","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2339,"division_number":504,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2339","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2336:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-22","title":"Draft Energy Prices Act 2022 (Extension of Time Limit) Regulations 2026","safe_summary":"Draft Energy Prices Act 2022 (Extension of Time Limit) Regulations 2026","topics":["draft energy prices act 2022 (extension of time limit) regulations 2026"],"matching_terms":["Draft Energy Prices Act 2022 (Extension of Time Limit) Regulations 2026","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2336,"division_number":501,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2336","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2335:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 98","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 98","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 98","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 98","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 98","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2335,"division_number":500,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2335","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2334:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 41","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 41","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 41","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 41","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 41","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2334,"division_number":499,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2334","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2333:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 37","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 37","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 37","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 37","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 37","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2333,"division_number":498,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2333","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2332:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 36","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 36","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 36","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 36","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 36","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2332,"division_number":497,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2332","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2331:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 26","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 26","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 26","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 26","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 26","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2331,"division_number":496,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2331","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2330:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 13","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 13","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 13","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 13","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 13","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2330,"division_number":495,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2330","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2329:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 4","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 4","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 4","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 4","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 4","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2329,"division_number":494,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2329","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2328:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-21","title":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 2","safe_summary":"English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 2","topics":["english devolution and community empowerment bill: government motion to disagree to lords amendment 2","english devolution community empowerment bill","to disagree to 2","english devolution and community empowerment bill"],"matching_terms":["English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill: Government motion to disagree to Lords Amendment 2","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2328,"division_number":493,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2328","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FD761C99-DE60-4779-A5CD-5591020E2355","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am not going to second-guess how the judges will apply this. As I say, that is for the judiciary and the courts. I...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-FD761C99-DE60-4779-A5CD-5591020E2355","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FBFA4B98-97CB-4374-BBEA-9A09BB9700F3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"Will the hon. Member acknowledge that one of the first things this Government did when we came into power was invest...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-FBFA4B98-97CB-4374-BBEA-9A09BB9700F3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:EFA635C1-92BC-4278-9F68-DC394D4EBCCB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I beg to move amendment 10, in clause 6, page 16, line 2, at end insert— “( ) in subsection (1)— (i) after ‘imposes’...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-EFA635C1-92BC-4278-9F68-DC394D4EBCCB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:EDAF33C8-9988-4C2E-999C-618EBB0C2A23","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"In that case I will deal with amendments 30 to 32 once I have addressed amendments 29 and 61, because they all touch...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-EDAF33C8-9988-4C2E-999C-618EBB0C2A23","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E46D0270-57EF-4075-AAEA-27C673B3A411","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Seventh sitting)","safe_summary":"It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair once again, Ms Jardine. As Members will have heard me say on countless occas...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (seventh sitting)","courts tribunals bill seventh sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Seventh sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/a5c51556-b9ed-44fd-b08f-70e52fff48f3/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSeventhSitting#contribution-E46D0270-57EF-4075-AAEA-27C673B3A411","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E0913171-CD83-4827-ADFD-4C34CB923ECC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for his amendment, which would require cases to be eligible for an order under proposed new s...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-E0913171-CD83-4827-ADFD-4C34CB923ECC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CBF160ED-3727-4959-AC4F-7ED7926B9721","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the shadow Minister for tabling amendment 51. I will first set out the rationale for clause 4 and schedule 1...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-CBF160ED-3727-4959-AC4F-7ED7926B9721","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CA0E3B7A-F544-4069-93D9-D91D0A33BEC9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I was about to get to the essential position, which is that what I said on Thursday is twofold. What we were debating...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-CA0E3B7A-F544-4069-93D9-D91D0A33BEC9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C69EDD12-E374-4F0C-A022-20811D416337","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"Clause 6 introduces a measure to extend the Secretary of State’s regulation-making power to enable the general limit...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-C69EDD12-E374-4F0C-A022-20811D416337","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:BA704275-4486-4FC4-A7FB-044E1BD7DCE2","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for her point, which has been raised by others. Those terms are well understood in their ordi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-BA704275-4486-4FC4-A7FB-044E1BD7DCE2","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B491E187-7CE7-4510-A039-28E4ED6640C8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"We consider it to be set out in clause 4 as drafted. It is sufficiently flexible and will no doubt be subjected to in...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-B491E187-7CE7-4510-A039-28E4ED6640C8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B3D51B33-572B-46AA-83F8-D9DD8F1C197D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"On amendment 49, consistent with our approach to the allocation of cases within the existing caseload but where trial...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-B3D51B33-572B-46AA-83F8-D9DD8F1C197D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:AFB2D79E-0D91-469B-A88E-C18B836BC74B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think we are maybe dancing on the head of a pin. Whether it is a concession or not, I accept that there is no right...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-AFB2D79E-0D91-469B-A88E-C18B836BC74B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A7134244-27A3-4382-A08F-70E8C8DC795B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"To be clear, I intend to address amendment 29, albeit that it is not being put to a vote, and amendment 46, which was...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-A7134244-27A3-4382-A08F-70E8C8DC795B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9D96C616-1F1F-468A-BA93-7C2B96D429E7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"On that final point, we are all delighted to be here and perform the function of Government properly. [Hon. Members:...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-9D96C616-1F1F-468A-BA93-7C2B96D429E7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9D5C2B21-C14E-4245-B6D9-905785EBF478","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"My hon. Friend is right. Flexibility is not a weaking of the safeguards; it is what actually allows the statutory tes...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-9D5C2B21-C14E-4245-B6D9-905785EBF478","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8AC1FCF0-A2FF-4F08-B063-DF92F6F712C1","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am not going to give way. For all those reasons, I commend the clause to the Committee. Question put, That the clau...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-8AC1FCF0-A2FF-4F08-B063-DF92F6F712C1","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:7B180CC8-19FE-4DF7-A523-6185597A40F1","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"As regards the last point, Ms Butler, I am ultimately in your hands as to how you want to deal with it. I have said h...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-7B180CC8-19FE-4DF7-A523-6185597A40F1","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:790A7504-96FA-4AA8-9DC2-2B79BA4259E5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"Members have asked about the intended impact of the clause. As I explained earlier, the reason why we are making this...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-790A7504-96FA-4AA8-9DC2-2B79BA4259E5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:72C3208C-035A-4F4B-8321-FED05F3C8DDB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I refer the hon. Gentleman to pages 243 and 245 of the independent review. If we want to come back on the detail, we...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-72C3208C-035A-4F4B-8321-FED05F3C8DDB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:719A1672-8173-400F-AF57-D0CD8DA89502","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am not sure that is right. I think we have all agreed—even those Opposition Members who were responsible for the ju...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-719A1672-8173-400F-AF57-D0CD8DA89502","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6B9461A3-48EF-44D2-8437-7472EB2BA9AE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"One of the things we have to in order to successfully deliver this court transformation is properly resource our magi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-6B9461A3-48EF-44D2-8437-7472EB2BA9AE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:677B411C-5801-42B2-B58B-A95691582FE8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I do not have any modelling to hand, but I can certainly take that away. If that work has been done, I will let the h...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-677B411C-5801-42B2-B58B-A95691582FE8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6542C324-2794-42F0-9DA7-1D28284020AC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"A number of the points just made were covered in earlier debates. I do not intend to rehearse the Government’s case f...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-6542C324-2794-42F0-9DA7-1D28284020AC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:620DE286-C283-41A0-8523-BFDBD3B87902","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"On a point of order, Ms Jardine. I ask for your guidance. We hear the rehearsal of a number of the same arguments tha...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-620DE286-C283-41A0-8523-BFDBD3B87902","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:5D6D19CA-E817-47AB-BCCA-1E4C0F3B70D8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"My understanding of the time saving—we measure it in the context of Crown court sitting days—is that we are looking a...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-5D6D19CA-E817-47AB-BCCA-1E4C0F3B70D8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:593389FC-CE97-4EF0-9891-B4428F3F2AAB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"Several points have been raised in this debate. First, on the definition and the application of the eligibility test,...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-593389FC-CE97-4EF0-9891-B4428F3F2AAB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:547CE377-2631-4C00-A322-010AB2D1F569","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"Forgive me, Ms Butler, is it possible that I have not addressed the amendment tabled by the hon. Member for Bexhill a...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-547CE377-2631-4C00-A322-010AB2D1F569","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:52FB4B81-5E7D-483E-B20D-C531CA0A2AB8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"The amendment would effectively introduce a new right of appeal against a decision to order a judge-only trial. Once...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-52FB4B81-5E7D-483E-B20D-C531CA0A2AB8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:499692BF-467D-4277-98F0-960A5B64838F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"We have already covered a fair amount of the same ground. The example that I gave a couple of sittings ago was in rel...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-499692BF-467D-4277-98F0-960A5B64838F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:494652B4-72CC-40A3-AADF-3F67A1B08028","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for Chichester for tabling the amendment, because the issue and importance of legal aid is so...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-494652B4-72CC-40A3-AADF-3F67A1B08028","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:494262BA-0902-477C-A499-813717EFA35E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"Finally, let me address amendment 46. As Members will get sick of hearing me say, the courts are facing an unpreceden...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-494262BA-0902-477C-A499-813717EFA35E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3F614635-62F5-4A5C-8F00-365ECDD7321F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"The Government have deliberately drafted clause 4 in a manner that focuses on the overall nature of the case, rather...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-3F614635-62F5-4A5C-8F00-365ECDD7321F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3DC3402E-B45C-4E4F-AE83-4637D309A550","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will make a bit of progress. We also need to be mindful of the burden that lengthy trials place on jurors. In this...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-3DC3402E-B45C-4E4F-AE83-4637D309A550","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3A758046-7A27-41C9-9412-284199DA9930","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"Amendment 10 is a technical amendment concerning magistrates court sentencing powers when imposing consecutive senten...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-3A758046-7A27-41C9-9412-284199DA9930","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:36057A15-A622-4BFC-89B2-018C98E84E32","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am going to make some progress— I know the hon. Gentleman has raised this with me. Those responsible for drafting t...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-36057A15-A622-4BFC-89B2-018C98E84E32","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:30C0E0CF-17EA-4D0C-967E-3D91033CF0B5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Sheffield Central and the hon. Members for Bexhill and Battle and for Chicheste...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-30C0E0CF-17EA-4D0C-967E-3D91033CF0B5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:2F106D12-7762-4064-AC1A-CA6AF41F2FDA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will address amendments 50 and 48 together. The cases that we are considering in the context of clause 4, which inv...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-2F106D12-7762-4064-AC1A-CA6AF41F2FDA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1CE5320A-1DA8-4F6A-8887-CC5B062F6D7D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"indicated assent. Question put, That the amendment be made.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-1CE5320A-1DA8-4F6A-8887-CC5B062F6D7D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1A1D2594-723F-4F6C-A52E-3EA18191BDAD","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I oppose the Adjournment because I want us to make progress. Everyone is here to continue the important work of line-...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-1A1D2594-723F-4F6C-A52E-3EA18191BDAD","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:14CB7666-023A-4732-B615-75A7E4FD63DE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"An important point was discussed in earlier exchanges with the hon. Member for Isle of Wight East. While I absolutely...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-14CB7666-023A-4732-B615-75A7E4FD63DE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0FFF1080-F056-4D86-8381-277E9BD9CA1B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will not; I am going to make some progress. As Sir Brian’s report clearly outlines, “this is a principled reform ba...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-0FFF1080-F056-4D86-8381-277E9BD9CA1B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0155274B-19E4-431A-AFA6-45E57E6EE61B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-21","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think I did clarify; I do not think I have anything more to say. I clarified it in answer to the hon. Member for Wi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (eighth sitting)","courts tribunals bill eighth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-21/debates/436e0c54-8e3c-4b44-8bf2-ec1db33f89e9/CourtsAndTribunalsBillEighthSitting#contribution-0155274B-19E4-431A-AFA6-45E57E6EE61B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2327:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-20","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating Lords Reasons 359B and 439B","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating Lords Reasons 359B and 439B","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion relating lords reasons 359b and 439b","crime policing bill","relating reasons 359b 439b"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating Lords Reasons 359B and 439B","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2327,"division_number":492,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2327","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2326:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-20","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 342B","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 342B","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion relating to lords reason 342b","crime policing bill","relating to reason 342b"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 342B","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2326,"division_number":491,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2326","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2325:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-20","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 11B","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 11B","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion relating to lords reason 11b","crime policing bill","relating to reason 11b"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Reason 11B","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2325,"division_number":490,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2325","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2324:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-20","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 2D and 2E","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 2D and 2E","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion relating to lords amendments 2d and 2e","crime policing bill","relating to 2d 2e"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: Motion relating to Lords Amendments 2D and 2E","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2324,"division_number":489,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2324","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FEFB9E93-1D74-4924-86CF-8BF2C94418A9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"Just on that point—as unlikely and rare a scenario as I anticipate it would be—would the hon. Member accept that that...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-FEFB9E93-1D74-4924-86CF-8BF2C94418A9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F5EFC364-6B24-42D7-8C32-D0C0392CDC5F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I appreciate that the Opposition disagree with what we have decided to do in this legislation. There is no specific r...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-F5EFC364-6B24-42D7-8C32-D0C0392CDC5F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F320D555-67EF-4496-9DAD-AA23AAEF46C9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"I do not want to labour the analogy—forgive the pun—but in many senses, we do allow that. Under this system and the r...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-F320D555-67EF-4496-9DAD-AA23AAEF46C9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F2BC8FBE-D596-434C-A7A9-970B893AAD9E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"What circumstances does the hon. Member envisage would trigger that reallocation? The allocation has been made—it has...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-F2BC8FBE-D596-434C-A7A9-970B893AAD9E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E97C8CF1-2178-4452-B742-B7625CC7E3C8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"As I am about to come on to, not least to address the very fair questions raised by the hon. Member for Reigate—she k...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-E97C8CF1-2178-4452-B742-B7625CC7E3C8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E8A2FFCD-1942-4D41-951C-4882B82E9A79","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"Further to that point of order, Dr Huq. I am happy to respond. We were probably at cross purposes. There was obviousl...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-E8A2FFCD-1942-4D41-951C-4882B82E9A79","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E39B444D-8773-4480-8213-320C420285A8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Member asks a typically great question. We did think about it. I am well aware that the right to elect exist...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-E39B444D-8773-4480-8213-320C420285A8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DFF6C667-79B0-4D25-8D0F-9B0F9E6251FE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"Miscarriage of justice should concern us all. That is why I am happy to see the responsibility for looking into misca...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-DFF6C667-79B0-4D25-8D0F-9B0F9E6251FE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DBC890DB-5C62-41F0-AADE-31D8A26EF6CC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me begin by making it absolutely clear that the deployment of judicial resource is properly a matter for the inde...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-DBC890DB-5C62-41F0-AADE-31D8A26EF6CC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DB88562E-4144-423E-ACDF-7B8A619E80C0","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"There is no specific ability to appeal, but of course, a decision in relation to mode of trial could be subject to ju...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-DB88562E-4144-423E-ACDF-7B8A619E80C0","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DA14C3AD-1563-4053-8106-63B2D884216A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will not stray into judicial discretion about how they would do this, but I think that that is highly unlikely. One...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-DA14C3AD-1563-4053-8106-63B2D884216A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D5B1F91C-1B97-4742-B8B0-2D68DC343786","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"Under the provisions, where a jury trial has started, it cannot be reallocated to the CCBD.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-D5B1F91C-1B97-4742-B8B0-2D68DC343786","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C49C611F-F7C7-4578-A229-73FEA074E10A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me intervene, because the omission was certainly not deliberate. I am trying to make progress, for the sake of th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-C49C611F-F7C7-4578-A229-73FEA074E10A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C0E2223D-8C1A-4579-8C51-F3A6E79B0E2B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"If, at a PTPH, a judge makes an error of law, that is amenable to judicial review. Full stop.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-C0E2223D-8C1A-4579-8C51-F3A6E79B0E2B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B7D9752C-6E04-4BD2-8B86-03088984599E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"It is not just me saying that; Sir Brian Leveson and the independent review of the criminal courts take that view, as...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-B7D9752C-6E04-4BD2-8B86-03088984599E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B3BBC6B9-8838-497C-97AE-770DC7916EE8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"I appreciate that my hon. Friend was not present for all the evidence sessions, but I wonder whether she would reflec...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-B3BBC6B9-8838-497C-97AE-770DC7916EE8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A7536519-CC77-49C2-B7FF-A7A1BFABAFA8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am not quite sure, in that hypothetical, where those arguments would take us. As I said, the allocation—whatever th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-A7536519-CC77-49C2-B7FF-A7A1BFABAFA8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A5CED100-BC63-48EC-AB70-2268C9300602","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"I do not accept the premise or assumption that everybody has a positive experience of the criminal justice system whe...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-A5CED100-BC63-48EC-AB70-2268C9300602","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9FD2EB09-27AE-4312-B0C2-D851F02A8097","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"Of course nobody is infallible in this process, and mistakes are made. But I caution that there is a distinction betw...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-9FD2EB09-27AE-4312-B0C2-D851F02A8097","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9FAC6488-74EF-41AC-BFFF-3649E80D3861","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Bolton South and Walkde...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-9FAC6488-74EF-41AC-BFFF-3649E80D3861","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9F3C4912-5E45-4E6D-8ABD-6A185D50286B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am going to make some progress. Amendment 18 would introduce a new right to appeal allocation or reallocation deter...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-9F3C4912-5E45-4E6D-8ABD-6A185D50286B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:98DB58B2-ED49-498A-BDE4-FBA91A1CD983","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"The premise of not just these amendments, but amendments that we have already debated, is that other tiers of the sys...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-98DB58B2-ED49-498A-BDE4-FBA91A1CD983","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9280BE41-01AA-4A7B-9238-774EDFAABD84","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will endeavour to do just that, Ms Jardine. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Bolton South and Walkden and the...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-9280BE41-01AA-4A7B-9238-774EDFAABD84","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:90D899C5-C1BA-4737-AD3C-E204C338556B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"My understanding, and I will happily correct the record if I am wrong, is that there is no bar to judicial review in...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-90D899C5-C1BA-4737-AD3C-E204C338556B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:903A0B3B-D6F8-41B6-B095-1A1D47C3134C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"We do think this is the right balance, which is why we brought it forward. It is the test that was recommended to us...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-903A0B3B-D6F8-41B6-B095-1A1D47C3134C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:892FECDF-D7B8-4774-B18B-639BB4387845","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will seek, as best I can, to clarify why judges sitting alone should have full Crown court sentencing powers consis...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-892FECDF-D7B8-4774-B18B-639BB4387845","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:81241C1F-08E0-4BB0-AD6E-EA4098A90C47","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"As I have said consistently throughout this debate, we regard jury trials as a cornerstone of British justice. They a...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-81241C1F-08E0-4BB0-AD6E-EA4098A90C47","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:7DA6C8FB-50F8-4DCF-8366-F4391AB9E91F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for Chichester for tabling amendment 19. I reiterate how grateful we are to Sir Brian Leveson...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-7DA6C8FB-50F8-4DCF-8366-F4391AB9E91F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:7C976DBC-52DE-4FC8-A223-F5888F13EDB3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am happy to sit down with the hon. Member again to clarify what she means by summary. There is no curtailment of th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-7C976DBC-52DE-4FC8-A223-F5888F13EDB3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:7AA446D8-610A-4087-A3E5-86DC5E8B6688","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"It is a good question and one that we touched on in our earlier debate in the context of clause 1, where we were disc...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-7AA446D8-610A-4087-A3E5-86DC5E8B6688","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:73922EC2-8C30-4FE0-BCED-73D9F57AEAC7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"The circumstances of the Post Office Horizon scandal are incredibly serious. Part of the reason why they came about i...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-73922EC2-8C30-4FE0-BCED-73D9F57AEAC7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:736C7901-DC8F-4DA8-BFB6-5A0DDB51825F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Bolton South and Walkden, who is no longer in her place, and the hon. Member fo...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-736C7901-DC8F-4DA8-BFB6-5A0DDB51825F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:5FEF0644-8873-41F0-8ED5-A6F2D91165D1","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"If I may say so, and as long as it is not indiscreet, my hon. Friend seems far younger and more energetic than she cl...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-5FEF0644-8873-41F0-8ED5-A6F2D91165D1","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:5E252714-6B16-4979-9CD4-6A9B6024AC9C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I did say that.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-5E252714-6B16-4979-9CD4-6A9B6024AC9C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:50A1E8A6-0EC1-4532-9D46-D45904F928C3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"The point that I was making is that it should be the seriousness of the case that is the sole dictator of the mode of...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-50A1E8A6-0EC1-4532-9D46-D45904F928C3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4E3B5579-1383-4379-98A2-C3BE28AFDBCB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"What I am seeking to be clear on is that when we are talking about the trial being commenced—a perfectly good questio...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-4E3B5579-1383-4379-98A2-C3BE28AFDBCB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4AD3668E-8E31-4051-A7AE-83C96ABA52C7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"I have to make progress. Expanding the test for eligibility beyond seriousness would dilute the focus and risk underm...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-4AD3668E-8E31-4051-A7AE-83C96ABA52C7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:499D6F57-95E6-4500-AD13-6F6B201F0850","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"Once again, I thank the hon. Members for Bexhill and Battle and for Chichester and my hon. Friend the Member for Bolt...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-499D6F57-95E6-4500-AD13-6F6B201F0850","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:372E0F70-B21B-4CC1-9D49-CE9ABF381206","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"In fairness to the hon. Gentleman, and so that we can make progress, if he gives me a list of those cases at the end...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-372E0F70-B21B-4CC1-9D49-CE9ABF381206","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:2A27CF7D-3CCF-4381-8A2E-B3198B002245","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am rejecting the addition of any other carve-outs or exceptions beyond the test of seriousness that we lay down in...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-2A27CF7D-3CCF-4381-8A2E-B3198B002245","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:298E522F-3FF7-4DD5-8F5D-2F396099AB02","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am going to make some progress. Amendment 40 seeks to introduce an appeal route. The practical effect would be addi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-298E522F-3FF7-4DD5-8F5D-2F396099AB02","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1B0DC46C-BD2D-49D3-A6EF-AA087EB58F0F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"As we have heard extensively in evidence, whether from Sir Brian Leveson, the three experienced judges or our interna...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-1B0DC46C-BD2D-49D3-A6EF-AA087EB58F0F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1AA48BC9-63DE-48B9-B5B0-97683D5F45DE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"As ever, my hon. Friend raises a very good point. Overall in the country, 14% of our magistrates are drawn from black...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-1AA48BC9-63DE-48B9-B5B0-97683D5F45DE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:196C342D-44E0-4ADA-ACE4-B64D4FA33450","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am sorry: I did have that question noted down. The hon. Member will get an answer.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-196C342D-44E0-4ADA-ACE4-B64D4FA33450","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:171D51D3-7E34-45BB-99D0-192A96067E8F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am going to make a little progress—","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-171D51D3-7E34-45BB-99D0-192A96067E8F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0DF6089C-4F5A-4D5C-8780-EAE252BF781B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am going to make some progress. Both parties will be able to make representations as I have said. We also recognise...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-0DF6089C-4F5A-4D5C-8780-EAE252BF781B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0DBEA4E7-0189-4894-95C4-2AF5585922CD","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think I have been as clear as I can be. If a mode-of-trial decision is so out of order or unlawful that it is chall...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (sixth sitting)","courts tribunals bill sixth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/71326544-5f6b-4e53-92e9-97d8f73d495d/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSixthSitting#contribution-0DBEA4E7-0189-4894-95C4-2AF5585922CD","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:03A40430-B4AA-4F72-BF0A-53D589222D5F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-16","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think there is some consensus here. We are all extolling the virtues of our system. As the Minister with responsibi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fifth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fifth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-16/debates/a6bb0041-8adb-42ef-9d98-4b5d75f77990/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFifthSitting#contribution-03A40430-B4AA-4F72-BF0A-53D589222D5F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2323:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-15","title":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 106","safe_summary":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 106","topics":["young people","children's wellbeing and schools bill: motion relating to lords amendment 106","children s wellbeing schools bill","relating to 106","children's wellbeing and schools bill"],"matching_terms":["Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 106","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2323,"division_number":488,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2323","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2322:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-15","title":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 102","safe_summary":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 102","topics":["young people","children's wellbeing and schools bill: motion relating to lords amendment 102","children s wellbeing schools bill","relating to 102","children's wellbeing and schools bill"],"matching_terms":["Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 102","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2322,"division_number":487,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2322","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2321:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-15","title":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 41B","safe_summary":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 41B","topics":["young people","children's wellbeing and schools bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 41b","children s wellbeing schools bill","to disagree 41b","children's wellbeing and schools bill"],"matching_terms":["Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 41B","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2321,"division_number":486,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2321","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2320:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-15","title":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 38","safe_summary":"Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 38","topics":["young people","children's wellbeing and schools bill: motion relating to lords amendment 38","children s wellbeing schools bill","relating to 38","children's wellbeing and schools bill"],"matching_terms":["Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill: motion relating to Lords Amendment 38","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2320,"division_number":485,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2320","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2311:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to agree with all remaining Lords Amendments","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to agree with all remaining Lords Amendments","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to agree with all remaining lords amendments","crime policing bill","to agree all remaining"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to agree with all remaining Lords Amendments","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2311,"division_number":476,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2311","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2310:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 359","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 359","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 359","crime policing bill","to disagree 359"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 359","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2310,"division_number":475,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2310","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2309:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 357","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 357","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 357","crime policing bill","to disagree 357"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 357","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2309,"division_number":474,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2309","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2308:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 342","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 342","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 342","crime policing bill","to disagree 342"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 342","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2308,"division_number":473,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2308","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2306:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 334","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 334","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 334","crime policing bill","to disagree 334"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 334","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2306,"division_number":472,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2306","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2305:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 333","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 333","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 333","crime policing bill","to disagree 333"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 333","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2305,"division_number":471,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2305","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2304:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 311","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 311","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 311","crime policing bill","to disagree 311"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 311","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2304,"division_number":470,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2304","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2303:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 11","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 11","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 11","crime policing bill","to disagree 11"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 11","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2303,"division_number":469,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2303","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2300:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 2","safe_summary":"Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 2","topics":["crime and policing bill","crime and policing bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 2","crime policing bill","to disagree 2"],"matching_terms":["Crime and Policing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 2","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2300,"division_number":467,"shard_href":"votes/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2300","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FB1A337E-3C6F-4CB9-9F8B-42B0FA3F2DF9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"What about what Sir Brian said in his report? Is it not right that the report specifically gives the Government scope...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-FB1A337E-3C6F-4CB9-9F8B-42B0FA3F2DF9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F7B99072-B121-4A4E-9759-7A7EC685D8B5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"My hon. Friend is absolutely right. We often use the old adage about justice needing not just to be done, but to be s...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-F7B99072-B121-4A4E-9759-7A7EC685D8B5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F0731A5B-A600-454F-956D-8BF0F0B6C292","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Given that the hon. Gentleman is besmirching my reputation, I should say that the equivalent is saying, “Health Secre...","topics":["health","courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-F0731A5B-A600-454F-956D-8BF0F0B6C292","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E9138226-0B64-40C7-9DFB-5A8FA3FFCDAA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I accept that it cannot happen, but equally we do not know what happens in jury deliberation rooms. We do not know ho...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-E9138226-0B64-40C7-9DFB-5A8FA3FFCDAA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E2E92974-A668-4E99-81A8-3186D3990906","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me begin by saying that the Bill has been prepared with precisely the people and communities who elected us and g...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-E2E92974-A668-4E99-81A8-3186D3990906","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E2C802D0-3864-40F8-8C06-5CC8712782E9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"As I think I am hearing from the Opposition, given that clause 3 is really meaty and has lots of aspects and that, I...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-E2C802D0-3864-40F8-8C06-5CC8712782E9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E2C63D03-5734-402B-A814-8E3A444E5C41","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Does the hon. Gentleman recognise that the central insight of the independent review—independent of Government—was th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-E2C63D03-5734-402B-A814-8E3A444E5C41","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E1FE03B9-B4B5-4217-A9EA-C4BFD72AD06C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Does the shadow Minister recognise that, in the IFG’s report, one of the central insights was that the key drag on co...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-E1FE03B9-B4B5-4217-A9EA-C4BFD72AD06C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DC834A4B-B1EC-4A30-9A7A-F0E07F06D601","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I have to make a little progress. Let me turn to the detail of clause 1. Part of its function is to ensure consistenc...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-DC834A4B-B1EC-4A30-9A7A-F0E07F06D601","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DA027321-0BBD-4BCC-8658-76040A381FF8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me just finish my sentence. This whole debate is located around a relatively narrow group—although we are still t...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-DA027321-0BBD-4BCC-8658-76040A381FF8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D6067472-D246-46D2-A0D6-1053C5FAF59A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"We do think that jury trials are a cornerstone of British justice. It is not inconsistent to say that the most seriou...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-D6067472-D246-46D2-A0D6-1053C5FAF59A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D493361F-B7B7-4C1A-B25F-04E4E859EB33","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me finish my sentence; you asked me the question. We are removing the right to elect, and removing it completely....","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-D493361F-B7B7-4C1A-B25F-04E4E859EB33","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D33CE2D5-6544-4DBC-B466-09A169A9C6D5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I am not sure who to give way to, but I will give way first to the hon. Lady—I will try to be as fair as I can.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-D33CE2D5-6544-4DBC-B466-09A169A9C6D5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D2EF93E5-BCFF-496D-BD53-AD8B3834942F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me just finish the point on clause 1, if I may. As I was saying in answer to a colleague’s question, the approach...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-D2EF93E5-BCFF-496D-BD53-AD8B3834942F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CA2BD120-B6F5-465D-BC67-B32313CB8C7C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I will not take any more interventions; I want to make progress. The point is that we are already beginning to see th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-CA2BD120-B6F5-465D-BC67-B32313CB8C7C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:BE67E30E-8510-49AE-9CA1-60D66C62EAC8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"No, I will not accept that it is inferior. I maintain the position that it is proportionate to the severity of the ca...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-BE67E30E-8510-49AE-9CA1-60D66C62EAC8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:BD185916-71B4-4281-A6BC-7DB1459C2472","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am glad to hear the Conservatives’ concern about legal aid and, yes, of course I am, as the Minister responsible fo...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-BD185916-71B4-4281-A6BC-7DB1459C2472","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B8F37749-A312-4E53-A668-2E538F2342DA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Will the shadow Minister give way?","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-B8F37749-A312-4E53-A668-2E538F2342DA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B6983361-6AD9-4BDD-9F95-A6FEE8E6A6AD","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I will just conclude this point. The central insight of the independent review of the criminal courts, in direct answ...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-B6983361-6AD9-4BDD-9F95-A6FEE8E6A6AD","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B43412FB-1E6D-48FC-8531-FE154A8861AD","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I appreciate the complexity. We are slightly in the realm of the hypothetical. To be absolutely clear, the purpose of...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-B43412FB-1E6D-48FC-8531-FE154A8861AD","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B349454E-0EC5-4B2A-B3AC-01D988B2F981","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"The moment has passed.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-B349454E-0EC5-4B2A-B3AC-01D988B2F981","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B1BE6A74-9699-4032-9454-2FF39DC22D71","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I will address clause 2 and respond to some of the remarks the hon. Member for Isle of Wight East made about the equa...","topics":["women and equalities","courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-B1BE6A74-9699-4032-9454-2FF39DC22D71","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:AD2A8ACC-5166-474B-AFDC-CB849F817A48","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"We have an obligation to guarantee a fair trial. I believe that wherever cases are heard in this system, they will be...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-AD2A8ACC-5166-474B-AFDC-CB849F817A48","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A69FE1B3-9CCA-4B62-8A91-292C7A418F55","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Does the hon. Gentleman accept that the very same sentence that he is quoting, which admits the fact that there is a...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-A69FE1B3-9CCA-4B62-8A91-292C7A418F55","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:92F68465-F10A-40BC-84EB-29A1040CADBC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I will make a little progress. As I have said, where a magistrates court has determined that an offence is suitable f...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-92F68465-F10A-40BC-84EB-29A1040CADBC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8CCF5533-9454-47F8-A797-EBDCF1249FD5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"We do not necessarily accept that that is why. There may be all sorts of reasons, which need to be unpacked, and that...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-8CCF5533-9454-47F8-A797-EBDCF1249FD5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:880AF394-9C36-400B-85F2-F238E89D5171","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I am going to make a little progress. The point is that our magistrates court, trials before district judges and the...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-880AF394-9C36-400B-85F2-F238E89D5171","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:866F77D5-8A79-4F3B-A85A-60D63913E6DA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Does the shadow Minister accept, though, that the legislation as drafted contains a number of guardrails? They includ...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-866F77D5-8A79-4F3B-A85A-60D63913E6DA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:799D210A-7A6A-4990-9250-DDB29E9932D8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I think the shadow Minister misunderstands me. I am not critiquing our jury trials which, as I have said, are a corne...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-799D210A-7A6A-4990-9250-DDB29E9932D8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:76429DE5-6043-43F6-93CD-C5F36B737C41","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Let me finish my point. I find it incongruous and arguably inconsistent when I hear Members say that the ideal form o...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-76429DE5-6043-43F6-93CD-C5F36B737C41","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:730CC958-FDC6-4BFD-99DB-7CE1D10A8A74","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"For those watching on TV—which is probably my mum—I will be absolutely clear: the Government are not abolishing jury...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-730CC958-FDC6-4BFD-99DB-7CE1D10A8A74","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:706C8DD2-E297-4A4A-8DBB-F27DA740554C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Will the hon. Member give way?","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-706C8DD2-E297-4A4A-8DBB-F27DA740554C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6C5E8C42-FA54-487D-8B05-7C788BE91899","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Butler. As I was saying earlier, when I was cut off mid-flow, clau...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-6C5E8C42-FA54-487D-8B05-7C788BE91899","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:675CF131-5912-4FF9-8CFD-47132279BBCA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Does the hon. Gentleman recognise that Sir Brian, in his report, gave scope for the Government to go further than his...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-675CF131-5912-4FF9-8CFD-47132279BBCA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:66A49EEA-8B48-47DD-AB4A-87D7F728B86B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I heard the evidence from Tim Crosland. I put to him that some of the cases he mentioned, including the Elbit Systems...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-66A49EEA-8B48-47DD-AB4A-87D7F728B86B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6368AD0E-FBDA-4418-869D-ABAF969A1F7B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I refer the hon. Member to the summary factsheet that was produced, which shows all of what I have described very cle...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-6368AD0E-FBDA-4418-869D-ABAF969A1F7B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:63373A47-DA1F-4EA0-853B-7CC29DDE671E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"We know that people would rather be in the Crown court because, when they have a right to elect, some opt for that. I...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-63373A47-DA1F-4EA0-853B-7CC29DDE671E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:5EF85306-70CD-4E4F-8A5A-1448DC26B62C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Of course, judges sitting alone do sentence. I understand the point the hon. Member is making in relation to the Crow...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-5EF85306-70CD-4E4F-8A5A-1448DC26B62C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:5CD063F0-2950-4C62-8A46-13ED1B8878DB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I am well versed in how our legal system works. I am well versed in the principle of the idea of innocent until prove...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-5CD063F0-2950-4C62-8A46-13ED1B8878DB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:58D90E1B-6C5F-405A-A2E5-81F286192E5B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"The clause sits alongside clause 1 and ensures that the new allocation framework will operate coherently following th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-58D90E1B-6C5F-405A-A2E5-81F286192E5B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:56A3B9FB-34A7-4650-8CA9-FC5F6D1474FA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"Of course, the Post Office Horizon scandal was one of the great miscarriages of justice of recent times. However, it...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-56A3B9FB-34A7-4650-8CA9-FC5F6D1474FA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4FB01272-CE0E-472E-B2C4-132A3A755F4E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"Of course that is right. No one is talking about the abolition of jury trials. We have said, and I will say repeatedl...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-4FB01272-CE0E-472E-B2C4-132A3A755F4E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4D44382C-BD04-4832-A2C5-677562999E20","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"On that specific point about appeals, a tiny fraction of cases—I do not have the figure in front of me, but I am happ...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-4D44382C-BD04-4832-A2C5-677562999E20","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4AB7F475-8543-401E-BA8D-6859B3951E2E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I have visited lots and lots of courts.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-4AB7F475-8543-401E-BA8D-6859B3951E2E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4852F68F-641D-47D2-B800-9962E4FDC7C3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I have never sought to sugar-coat the situation in our courts. Does the hon. Member think that one of the reasons why...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-4852F68F-641D-47D2-B800-9962E4FDC7C3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:477A55E9-05D0-4E24-902F-6AE5DE9F0AA5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"We are working hard.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-477A55E9-05D0-4E24-902F-6AE5DE9F0AA5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:472DB0B8-6BCF-425F-9A7F-51C40F4FA870","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Does the hon. Gentleman agree that the 1% to 2% refers to the time savings achieved by the Crown court bench division...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-472DB0B8-6BCF-425F-9A7F-51C40F4FA870","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:46484F8B-90FE-439E-8155-83D735AA6A18","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I will give way to my hon. Friend.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-46484F8B-90FE-439E-8155-83D735AA6A18","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:451D9E76-DD6B-49ED-A02A-EAEBF9DC0224","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"I was coming to that point, but as the hon. Member has raised it, I will address it now. First, I put it on record th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-451D9E76-DD6B-49ED-A02A-EAEBF9DC0224","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:413C0932-B55E-4662-AA5F-7BF006C3687B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"It would depend on the facts of the case. First, I do not entirely understand the rancour behind the examples. If som...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-413C0932-B55E-4662-AA5F-7BF006C3687B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3D057ECA-D792-4260-8885-7A54ED6080C8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"While I am very proud of our legal system, I do not necessarily take the view that ours is best and we cannot learn f...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-3D057ECA-D792-4260-8885-7A54ED6080C8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3C7E5928-8A82-4D13-8CCC-FC351A1C6777","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"Just to be absolutely clear, I have not accepted the CBA figures. What I have told you, and everyone here, is that on...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-3C7E5928-8A82-4D13-8CCC-FC351A1C6777","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3C0056F5-0FF3-41E5-9C8F-7BD1D6C9AFDC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Is the shadow Minister seriously saying that the giving of reasons, constrained by the legal tests that judges have t...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-3C0056F5-0FF3-41E5-9C8F-7BD1D6C9AFDC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:366B25C9-6149-4BB2-8F3F-33DA4CECCFC9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I do not think we are disagreeing about the importance of judicial accountability or the need for a more diverse judi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-366B25C9-6149-4BB2-8F3F-33DA4CECCFC9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:253BCD20-D776-414C-B1B7-1EF81470C51F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I do not want to interrupt the hon. Gentleman because he is making important points, but the point was well made a mo...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-253BCD20-D776-414C-B1B7-1EF81470C51F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:17AC36E7-0818-4575-84F9-75D4B267427A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Member is right. Where currently a defendant charged with a triable either-way offence has the ability to ch...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-17AC36E7-0818-4575-84F9-75D4B267427A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:16CEFE39-179C-452F-A7C2-D51F147F6A39","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"Absolutely; the comment from my hon. Friend the Member for Birmingham Erdington was really important. In fairness, th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-16CEFE39-179C-452F-A7C2-D51F147F6A39","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1516526A-CBE8-4E8C-8A12-AAFCD70BE294","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"What clause 1 does is remove the ability of a defendant to choose where they are tried, which, at the moment, they ha...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-1516526A-CBE8-4E8C-8A12-AAFCD70BE294","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1301BE2A-F209-4D4D-9EE9-C6A56055E7E9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"But does the shadow Minister accept that these things take time? His party is a great believer in the force of the ma...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-1301BE2A-F209-4D4D-9EE9-C6A56055E7E9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0CC2D5BE-7FDA-4D07-A69B-D005E47C9BB3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"I checked this during the adjournment of the sitting: the CBA’s point relates to new receipts in certain courts, rath...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-0CC2D5BE-7FDA-4D07-A69B-D005E47C9BB3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0AEE6D24-EDED-4CAF-80C9-4311EE665C68","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Member started with a long digression into trial by ordeal. I hope this Committee will not become a trial by...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-0AEE6D24-EDED-4CAF-80C9-4311EE665C68","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0357E61E-E6F6-4EC0-907E-F45466E55DF7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)","safe_summary":"No, it has a total air of unreality. If we look at the current system, I think we all agree that it is not working fo...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (fourth sitting)","courts tribunals bill fourth sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/77f62519-0133-4059-8f1b-505b98b321a0/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFourthSitting#contribution-0357E61E-E6F6-4EC0-907E-F45466E55DF7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:00F8D670-C60A-4F8E-9C60-8B8F19E48C4E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-04-14","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)","safe_summary":"The hon. Lady will have seen that with the presentation of the Bill, as is right and appropriate, a suite of document...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (third sitting)","courts tribunals bill third sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-04.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-04-14/debates/b56e4663-8fa0-4c8d-82ed-3a39b74537e2/CourtsAndTribunalsBillThirdSitting#contribution-00F8D670-C60A-4F8E-9C60-8B8F19E48C4E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2298:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 6","safe_summary":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 6","topics":["victims and courts bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 6","victims courts bill","to disagree 6","victims and courts bill"],"matching_terms":["Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 6","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2298,"division_number":466,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2298","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2297:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 5","safe_summary":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 5","topics":["victims and courts bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 5","victims courts bill","to disagree 5","victims and courts bill"],"matching_terms":["Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 5","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2297,"division_number":465,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2297","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2296:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with  Lords Amendment 4","safe_summary":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 4","topics":["victims and courts bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 4","victims courts bill","to disagree 4","victims and courts bill"],"matching_terms":["Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with  Lords Amendment 4","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2296,"division_number":464,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2296","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2295:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 3","safe_summary":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 3","topics":["victims and courts bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 3","victims courts bill","to disagree 3","victims and courts bill"],"matching_terms":["Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 3","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2295,"division_number":463,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2295","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2294:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 2","safe_summary":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 2","topics":["victims and courts bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 2","victims courts bill","to disagree 2","victims and courts bill"],"matching_terms":["Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 2","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2294,"division_number":462,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2294","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2293:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 1","safe_summary":"Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 1","topics":["victims and courts bill: motion to disagree with lords amendment 1","victims courts bill","to disagree 1","victims and courts bill"],"matching_terms":["Victims and Courts Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 1","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2293,"division_number":461,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2293","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:FC1703CA-4A1A-4374-B45D-CB72BCDAF19B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q The Government are seeking to take forward your proposal, in the independent review of the criminal courts, on the...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-FC1703CA-4A1A-4374-B45D-CB72BCDAF19B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F57A98D4-5301-402A-9B56-E0E8A230D381","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I am aware of that distinction. Distinguished academics such as Professor Hoyano have made the point about the dist...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-F57A98D4-5301-402A-9B56-E0E8A230D381","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E9457913-4CC4-4167-9D21-A5C8D066F1BC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Claire Waxman, you have been asked repeatedly about this letter. We have a witness from Women’s Aid coming later wh...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-E9457913-4CC4-4167-9D21-A5C8D066F1BC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D71BB6D6-17E3-407C-B837-5D96DD2A8D18","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q The point about the pace at which the trial moves is an issue of contention. Some people say that having judge-alon...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-D71BB6D6-17E3-407C-B837-5D96DD2A8D18","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D331106F-EA8A-4723-A1C2-81C056AAB0C1","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"In the one that you cited. Tim Crosland: In the Ponting case?","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-D331106F-EA8A-4723-A1C2-81C056AAB0C1","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D2C1BA70-4FED-44AE-9BD3-5AFC9D1176AE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q It was not purely criminal damage. There were indictable-only offences. That particular case would have still recei...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-D2C1BA70-4FED-44AE-9BD3-5AFC9D1176AE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D26593D7-B5FC-458A-882D-5B6F9B13FDEC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I want to be clear about the scope of this argument. Obviously, the least serious cases that take place in the cont...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-D26593D7-B5FC-458A-882D-5B6F9B13FDEC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CD4C6386-53C0-4A1A-9FDB-E98D9668CB58","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q You made the point across both parts of your comprehensive review that what is needed to address the crisis in the...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-CD4C6386-53C0-4A1A-9FDB-E98D9668CB58","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CBEB5F46-23ED-49BC-9904-23853F2F5B3D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I have one more question. It picks up on something that you said, Charlotte, but I am happy for others to comment i...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-CBEB5F46-23ED-49BC-9904-23853F2F5B3D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CBA81D07-0B02-4C74-8F04-9CD4A1B9CDE8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I would like to ask questions of the panel in relation to the practicality of what is being proposed, but also the...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-CBA81D07-0B02-4C74-8F04-9CD4A1B9CDE8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CA57792B-A431-415C-A197-BB7D4A36087D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I think there is consensus between us that we need to grow capacity in the criminal legal profession. I think where...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-CA57792B-A431-415C-A197-BB7D4A36087D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C8217FB0-8EFA-441D-9817-247648DA2634","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q The independent review of the criminal courts referred to the genesis of the crisis that we are in. It has been dri...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-C8217FB0-8EFA-441D-9817-247648DA2634","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C795888C-5BF2-4007-9416-17FC97D4AB43","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I am going to direct my questions to Ms Brimelow. I think we agree that the delays in our criminal justice system a...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-C795888C-5BF2-4007-9416-17FC97D4AB43","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C71BAEFF-989F-4E8A-B528-E18999228828","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q That is the point that I want to alight on. Lord Burnett, you were part of the Times crime and justice commission,...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-C71BAEFF-989F-4E8A-B528-E18999228828","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B19BE019-868C-44BE-9B48-DE3D87D549D7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Yes. Kirsty Brimelow: You asked the question; just let me answer. If you focus on that, then that is the way to get b...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-B19BE019-868C-44BE-9B48-DE3D87D549D7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B02DA150-DE32-4799-8C93-4B7329BABC54","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Is the same thing true for APPEAL? Emma Torr: Yes, but you have to understand that if you—","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-B02DA150-DE32-4799-8C93-4B7329BABC54","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A8D2DB65-660D-4AAE-9694-F6C1C1ED9188","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"I would not disagree with that for one second.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-A8D2DB65-660D-4AAE-9694-F6C1C1ED9188","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A8CC0021-0E17-41C8-9DC2-235E06651EFB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Thank you for being here, Mr Flury. You have clearly mentioned that certainty on uncapped sitting days is hugely va...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-A8CC0021-0E17-41C8-9DC2-235E06651EFB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A6FFEF5A-E790-4D70-81FE-A6E0A03B1814","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"No, that is not what is in the Bill. Mr Goldstone, I noticed you were nodding. Do you want to come in? Clement Goldst...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-A6FFEF5A-E790-4D70-81FE-A6E0A03B1814","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A405818E-BE5E-457C-9F07-0EFBF3EC15BD","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q My first question is for Professor Katrin Hohl. There are measures in the Bill that address the admissibility of ev...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-A405818E-BE5E-457C-9F07-0EFBF3EC15BD","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:A1C8924F-E0C0-492B-B8C7-AB4608014810","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q No doubt you would also welcome the investment the Government are making in uncapping sitting days and thereby remo...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-A1C8924F-E0C0-492B-B8C7-AB4608014810","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9B12CC91-2352-4B75-9BAD-F98576175AF9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q You have mentioned a number of ways in which HMCTS is pursuing greater efficiencies in the Crown court. Can you sha...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-9B12CC91-2352-4B75-9BAD-F98576175AF9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:954C0444-D28B-45EA-A117-82D18F81A18F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Coupled with the procedural safeguards—things like the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 and what have you, whi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-954C0444-D28B-45EA-A117-82D18F81A18F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:93C554F3-034C-4632-A288-B7F5152F3F7C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Just finally to Ms Davies, if I may, you said that efficiencies must be tried first. That argument has been aired v...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-93C554F3-034C-4632-A288-B7F5152F3F7C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8E17DA2D-474A-4B54-8F1F-8338013248B6","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Do you agree with me, on that major productivity driver that we need to address, that it will take years before we...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-8E17DA2D-474A-4B54-8F1F-8338013248B6","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8A8F2301-625D-4824-AC6E-E9DBB6C9F2C8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Thank you.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-8A8F2301-625D-4824-AC6E-E9DBB6C9F2C8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8593322D-59D0-49FE-BE26-46DED529869F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q On your point about challenge, I do not think anyone in this room would dispute the importance of the right to prot...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-8593322D-59D0-49FE-BE26-46DED529869F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6F9E16F5-921A-43C0-98EB-BC6C8C5D4F54","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q So you would agree with me that we cannot get those numbers of criminal lawyers back up to where they were overnigh...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-6F9E16F5-921A-43C0-98EB-BC6C8C5D4F54","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6DB062B2-D2FD-4278-B13B-4CCB445F3F3C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Yes, you do provide services to victims. Emma Torr: We provide services to individuals who have been wrongfully convi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-6DB062B2-D2FD-4278-B13B-4CCB445F3F3C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6C6B41BB-DE17-4F93-8D05-572B0CD28256","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q It would be helpful for the Committee to understand the impact that the delays, which I think we all agree are into...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-6C6B41BB-DE17-4F93-8D05-572B0CD28256","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:6B4D1B57-9048-4128-BC5F-B394F75168B9","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Thank you. Cassia Rowland: We are always banging the drum for more back office and admin staff at the IfG. I worry th...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-6B4D1B57-9048-4128-BC5F-B394F75168B9","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:685C6A34-480C-41ED-ADF5-17E7C2C32C29","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"No, not in the Ponting case. In the recent Elbit case. Tim Crosland: No, these were criminal damage cases.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-685C6A34-480C-41ED-ADF5-17E7C2C32C29","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:669CA610-AAC3-4D88-80DD-F1D821598162","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q So there was a cut in investment. There have been several things that we needed to do, some of which have been welc...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-669CA610-AAC3-4D88-80DD-F1D821598162","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:664A42EC-8F08-48DF-9460-8BD10BC7FB4D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Listing was just raised and, obviously, listing is not dealt with in the Bill; it is a judicial function. We have h...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-664A42EC-8F08-48DF-9460-8BD10BC7FB4D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:63786B9D-1E45-42DC-87D8-CAB66E2D0BBB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q That is welcomed. It also includes the introduction of match funding for criminal Bar pupillages; the need for acti...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-63786B9D-1E45-42DC-87D8-CAB66E2D0BBB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:57F89A82-F903-44E7-B756-ADDBD90A1BEA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Sir Brian, I would be grateful if you would elaborate for the Committee on the point you made about cultural change...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-57F89A82-F903-44E7-B756-ADDBD90A1BEA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:513128D4-059E-4DFC-95A3-169D6507643D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q You have proposed that thesis, and I will come to that in a moment. You make the point about the disruption that mi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-513128D4-059E-4DFC-95A3-169D6507643D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4372B77B-5BEC-4A84-B9FC-4A17F9806C9A","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Other Committee members want to come in, but I want to ask you about fairness and, importantly, the perceived fairn...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-4372B77B-5BEC-4A84-B9FC-4A17F9806C9A","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3F25B599-77BC-481A-BBF0-D3E994C27723","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q But the point is that low-level damage would receive a magistrates trial anyway. What I am talking about is the sco...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-3F25B599-77BC-481A-BBF0-D3E994C27723","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:341F9BA3-D564-432F-9E9B-4076D33DE42C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q There is no disagreement between us on the fact that we need to drive greater productivity and we want to get back...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-341F9BA3-D564-432F-9E9B-4076D33DE42C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3056AE1C-71F5-4740-A737-06B950FC0A7E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)","safe_summary":"Q Let me echo the shadow Minister’s thanks to you for being here. I appreciate that you have spoken in Parliament on...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (first sitting)","courts tribunals bill first sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (First sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/a7162ebf-a60e-4c8b-8ddc-ec0033fcc2d1/CourtsAndTribunalsBillFirstSitting#contribution-3056AE1C-71F5-4740-A737-06B950FC0A7E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:2F605714-B39D-476D-ABB7-60E011A0A53E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q We both agree that we need investment. We agree that we need to do a major drive on efficiency and the Government a...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-2F605714-B39D-476D-ABB7-60E011A0A53E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:2F12EAB4-57EF-412A-B9AC-818F878FEDC2","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q One final point. I am happy for each and any one of you to come in. There is certainly no twisting of figures. Thes...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-2F12EAB4-57EF-412A-B9AC-818F878FEDC2","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:25D5CD6F-698B-44E3-AAB0-9AEEFF900696","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q But not in anything like the numbers that we would need to address this issue. Cassia Rowland: No, it is not what y...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-25D5CD6F-698B-44E3-AAB0-9AEEFF900696","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:2437DB7C-EB0F-47C8-8800-557D321ACB41","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q You will have seen the conclusion of the independent review of criminal courts: that, notwithstanding maximum inves...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-2437DB7C-EB0F-47C8-8800-557D321ACB41","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1E9FAC76-DD8F-4261-8A14-1DF873E39C42","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Thank you, Claire, for sharing such a powerful testimony. I think I first met you during a Westminster Hall debate, w...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-1E9FAC76-DD8F-4261-8A14-1DF873E39C42","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:18F5DE2E-1A8D-495A-8A3D-467044247EA1","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q It is good to see you all again. We have had a number of engagements over the past year, so it is good to be able t...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-18F5DE2E-1A8D-495A-8A3D-467044247EA1","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:169402EF-10BE-47B3-96D7-1AF1FFFD562C","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"It is in the impact assessment. Claire Davies: The impact assessment does not provide data.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-169402EF-10BE-47B3-96D7-1AF1FFFD562C","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:14C13712-BCB8-481C-8561-955B65E50583","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I, too, have questions for the IfG and I agree—thank you very much for both your reports, which are incredibly help...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-14C13712-BCB8-481C-8561-955B65E50583","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0BDABE06-589F-4596-B25A-CB2CC82F0A50","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I do not want to hog the microphone, but I want to understand something about APPEAL and JUSTICE. We have had quite...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-0BDABE06-589F-4596-B25A-CB2CC82F0A50","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0A2470CD-7B42-4A90-84DD-778DF94A61C2","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q One of the examples you gave was the Elbit case. The indictment there was an indictable-only offence. There were mu...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-0A2470CD-7B42-4A90-84DD-778DF94A61C2","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:09E1E55B-3B85-4A01-960E-FD3A7608A0BC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"It is a good question. Can you answer it? Tim Crosland: I want to talk particularly about cases where people are sayi...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-09E1E55B-3B85-4A01-960E-FD3A7608A0BC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0877C43E-BCF9-43E7-A42E-BB64FC786845","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q I understand that you do not agree, but I do not understand that any of the circuits have produced independent evid...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-0877C43E-BCF9-43E7-A42E-BB64FC786845","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:08240364-1D21-4AF7-AACD-77D2C74F7488","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q And I think we agree that there have been multiple drivers of how we got here. One of those drivers was the real-te...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-08240364-1D21-4AF7-AACD-77D2C74F7488","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:07D21EA6-E10D-4761-B707-F3D4590CEC2B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q It was very good to have the chance to meet not just you, Mr Downey, but many of the judges at the superior court o...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-07D21EA6-E10D-4761-B707-F3D4590CEC2B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:060E5CC1-4E57-461E-807C-C6C8D62B07E6","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-25","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)","safe_summary":"Q We will come on to that in a second. I have a chance to ask questions of the IFG a little later. You have not put f...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill (second sitting)","courts tribunals bill second sitting"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill (Second sitting)"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-25/debates/36e6dc63-f10c-4e0d-a74e-fff92fba2686/CourtsAndTribunalsBillSecondSitting#contribution-060E5CC1-4E57-461E-807C-C6C8D62B07E6","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2292:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-24","title":"Opposition Day Motion: Defence","safe_summary":"Opposition Day Motion: Defence","topics":["opposition day motion: defence","opposition day","defence"],"matching_terms":["Opposition Day Motion: Defence","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2292,"division_number":460,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2292","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2291:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-24","title":"Opposition Day Motion: Oil and Gas","safe_summary":"Opposition Day Motion: Oil and Gas","topics":["opposition day motion: oil and gas","opposition day","oil gas"],"matching_terms":["Opposition Day Motion: Oil and Gas","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2291,"division_number":459,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2291","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2285:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-18","title":"Opposition day motion: student loans","safe_summary":"Opposition day motion: student loans","topics":["opposition day motion: student loans","opposition day","student loans"],"matching_terms":["Opposition day motion: student loans","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2285,"division_number":453,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2285","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2284:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-18","title":"Opposition day motion: fuel duty","safe_summary":"Opposition day motion: fuel duty","topics":["opposition day motion: fuel duty","opposition day","fuel duty"],"matching_terms":["Opposition day motion: fuel duty","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2284,"division_number":452,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2284","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"committee:837","source":"committees","date":"2026-03-18","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill","safe_summary":"Committee role: Courts and Tribunals Bill (Commons).","topics":["courts and tribunals bill","courts tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill"],"shard_href":"current-snapshot/index.json","official_url":"https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/837","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open the committee page for remit, membership, and latest updates.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F19E445A-1803-4A7A-8DF0-914FB59832C2","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Automated Enforcement Technology: Evidence","safe_summary":"We will keep the rules relating to the admissibility of evidence under review. When considering whether evidence is a...","topics":["automated enforcement technology: evidence","automated enforcement technology","evidence"],"matching_terms":["Automated Enforcement Technology: Evidence"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/614F6D2E-5185-44E7-A7EE-604490DA9F64/AutomatedEnforcementTechnologyEvidence#contribution-F19E445A-1803-4A7A-8DF0-914FB59832C2","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:F181C39A-D01F-4579-B849-01E2C6611606","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Transparency in Court Proceedings","safe_summary":"Of course, there are good reasons for the protection of jury deliberations, which ensures that they can happen in pri...","topics":["transparency in court proceedings"],"matching_terms":["Transparency in Court Proceedings"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/3F28A7F3-C3EE-47D9-B948-39B2B8DCB111/TransparencyInCourtProceedings#contribution-F181C39A-D01F-4579-B849-01E2C6611606","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:EEDDED53-5EE6-4302-94E7-1097E9E4FD25","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"We are maximising the number of judicial sitting days in the immigration and asylum chamber. We are recruiting more j...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-EEDDED53-5EE6-4302-94E7-1097E9E4FD25","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:EADC0C75-C9EA-455A-9830-90CAC24C4C5F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Automated Enforcement Technology: Evidence","safe_summary":"Might I echo—","topics":["automated enforcement technology: evidence","automated enforcement technology","evidence"],"matching_terms":["Automated Enforcement Technology: Evidence"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/614F6D2E-5185-44E7-A7EE-604490DA9F64/AutomatedEnforcementTechnologyEvidence#contribution-EADC0C75-C9EA-455A-9830-90CAC24C4C5F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:CA264EB5-DA2A-4588-88A6-07475E385D9B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Bailiffs","safe_summary":"Before answering the question, I extend my condolences to the family and friends of Jeff Blair, a county court bailif...","topics":["bailiffs"],"matching_terms":["Bailiffs"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/6A6380ED-13BF-4B4D-A542-E6DC5155DA9F/Bailiffs#contribution-CA264EB5-DA2A-4588-88A6-07475E385D9B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:C21B0B21-A73A-45CF-9ACA-95BC25ECD8AD","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Victims: Court Experience","safe_summary":"The Courts and Tribunals Bill puts victims at its heart and aims to deliver faster, fairer justice for all victims. I...","topics":["victims: court experience","victims","court experience"],"matching_terms":["Victims: Court Experience"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/42CE6884-CCF4-4BDD-A23E-F3D4105FF691/VictimsCourtExperience#contribution-C21B0B21-A73A-45CF-9ACA-95BC25ECD8AD","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B95EFA92-1BC1-40E0-9737-4E32FC383A92","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Automated Enforcement Technology: Evidence","safe_summary":"It is the prosecution and the defence who decide what evidence to put forward in a criminal trial, including deciding...","topics":["automated enforcement technology: evidence","automated enforcement technology","evidence"],"matching_terms":["Automated Enforcement Technology: Evidence"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/614F6D2E-5185-44E7-A7EE-604490DA9F64/AutomatedEnforcementTechnologyEvidence#contribution-B95EFA92-1BC1-40E0-9737-4E32FC383A92","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B5321781-6040-455D-B1FF-6B55D1AE60CB","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"Plainly, we have to address the backlogs in our immigration and asylum chamber. It is why we are maximising capacity...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-B5321781-6040-455D-B1FF-6B55D1AE60CB","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:9A0E8378-7B98-44B1-91E6-3D620EFAFF49","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Member for his question and his tireless advocacy, which is a way of honouring Sara, who was brutall...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-9A0E8378-7B98-44B1-91E6-3D620EFAFF49","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:93388693-F170-458B-892F-8B9BBBBF1CAE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Victims: Court Experience","safe_summary":"I thank the hon. Lady for raising an important point. The starting point is that judges decide what evidence is admis...","topics":["victims: court experience","victims","court experience"],"matching_terms":["Victims: Court Experience"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/42CE6884-CCF4-4BDD-A23E-F3D4105FF691/VictimsCourtExperience#contribution-93388693-F170-458B-892F-8B9BBBBF1CAE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:8C3A31BD-5156-4FE6-8600-6613193014D8","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Transparency in Court Proceedings","safe_summary":"I will start by reminding the House why we suspended the operations of Courtsdesk. It was because of its handling of...","topics":["transparency in court proceedings"],"matching_terms":["Transparency in Court Proceedings"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/3F28A7F3-C3EE-47D9-B948-39B2B8DCB111/TransparencyInCourtProceedings#contribution-8C3A31BD-5156-4FE6-8600-6613193014D8","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:635E5623-149E-43AF-B6FE-06CC2D023460","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"My hon. Friend is right: we are seeking to increase transparency and reduce barriers to justice. That is why we are l...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-635E5623-149E-43AF-B6FE-06CC2D023460","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:51A026B8-09E1-4AD2-A9E6-7B20B2B90CC3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"I am sorry to hear about that case. These sorts of delays mount trauma on trauma for many of those going through sens...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-51A026B8-09E1-4AD2-A9E6-7B20B2B90CC3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4DFC3E4D-96C6-4E62-8ECA-5262C96C1A3E","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Bailiffs","safe_summary":"I join my hon. Friend in endorsing the work of StepChange, in particular, in this campaign. The indignity that she de...","topics":["bailiffs"],"matching_terms":["Bailiffs"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/6A6380ED-13BF-4B4D-A542-E6DC5155DA9F/Bailiffs#contribution-4DFC3E4D-96C6-4E62-8ECA-5262C96C1A3E","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:461BBFD3-5557-4DBB-A04B-1A1317421097","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"The Renters Rights Act 2025 represents the biggest expansion of renters’ rights in a generation, but of course, right...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-461BBFD3-5557-4DBB-A04B-1A1317421097","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4415C82C-55FA-4610-AFED-00497EF84F45","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Bailiffs","safe_summary":"As much as we want to protect debtors, we also have to ensure that creditors who are owed money are able to recover t...","topics":["bailiffs"],"matching_terms":["Bailiffs"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/6A6380ED-13BF-4B4D-A542-E6DC5155DA9F/Bailiffs#contribution-4415C82C-55FA-4610-AFED-00497EF84F45","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:3C2B0238-B736-452D-A50A-3D93500BD8C3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"I entirely agree that the profound financial and psychological impact of SLAPPs, and the chilling effect that they ha...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-3C2B0238-B736-452D-A50A-3D93500BD8C3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:19A6AF8C-41FE-4B0C-972A-562C807015EE","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Transparency in Court Proceedings","safe_summary":"This Government are dedicated to increasing transparency in our courts. We are expanding free Crown court sentencing...","topics":["transparency in court proceedings"],"matching_terms":["Transparency in Court Proceedings"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/3F28A7F3-C3EE-47D9-B948-39B2B8DCB111/TransparencyInCourtProceedings#contribution-19A6AF8C-41FE-4B0C-972A-562C807015EE","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0DE39268-C41C-4F73-A888-E286AB854F00","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-17","title":"Topical Questions","safe_summary":"The impact of delays, as the hon. Gentleman rightly points out, is a feature of not just our criminal courts, but our...","topics":["topical questions","topical"],"matching_terms":["Topical Questions"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-17/debates/4C025E79-A940-4258-BD37-1FC767DA37DB/TopicalQuestions#contribution-0DE39268-C41C-4F73-A888-E286AB854F00","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:019A0364-3962-4B9E-8DC9-0DE66D45833F","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-16","title":"Asbestos-related Lung Cancer: Compensation Act 2006","safe_summary":"I thank my hon. Friend the Member for West Dunbartonshire (Douglas McAllister) for securing this debate. We have all...","topics":["health","asbestos-related lung cancer: compensation act 2006","asbestos","related lung cancer","compensation act 2006"],"matching_terms":["Asbestos-related Lung Cancer: Compensation Act 2006"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-16/debates/38440014-88A8-485E-B181-8AB96DFD327B/AsbestosRelatedLungCancerCompensationAct2006#contribution-019A0364-3962-4B9E-8DC9-0DE66D45833F","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:5F3403AA-21D4-4F04-961A-FF2059156CB0","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-12","title":"Marriage Regulations","safe_summary":"It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Sir Christopher. Let me start by reiterating the thanks that others h...","topics":["marriage regulations"],"matching_terms":["Marriage Regulations"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-12/debates/591ADC62-AC31-470C-8DC1-8E2C9CDF2B7D/MarriageRegulations#contribution-5F3403AA-21D4-4F04-961A-FF2059156CB0","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2277:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-10","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill: Second Reading","safe_summary":"Courts and Tribunals Bill: Second Reading","topics":["courts and tribunals bill: second reading","courts tribunals bill","second reading","courts and tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill: Second Reading","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2277,"division_number":445,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2277","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2276:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-03-10","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill: Reasoned Amendment to Second Reading","safe_summary":"Courts and Tribunals Bill: Reasoned Amendment to Second Reading","topics":["courts and tribunals bill: reasoned amendment to second reading","courts tribunals bill","reasoned to second reading","courts and tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill: Reasoned Amendment to Second Reading","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2276,"division_number":444,"shard_href":"votes/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2276","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:90975556-36EF-4C76-A32C-CB44B29962D3","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-10","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill","safe_summary":"I will give way, but I am mindful of the time. I have to wrap up on time.","topics":["courts and tribunals bill","courts tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-10/debates/CC3FC3F7-20F4-4923-918B-EBCBA40FE402/CourtsAndTribunalsBill#contribution-90975556-36EF-4C76-A32C-CB44B29962D3","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:79DEE33F-FA10-431E-8655-13FADEF63590","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-10","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill","safe_summary":"It is my pleasure to deliver the closing speech for this Second Reading of the Courts and Tribunals Bill. I thank rig...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill","courts tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-10/debates/CC3FC3F7-20F4-4923-918B-EBCBA40FE402/CourtsAndTribunalsBill#contribution-79DEE33F-FA10-431E-8655-13FADEF63590","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4A449EFA-909C-4C45-83DE-89F445926C70","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-10","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill","safe_summary":"I will not give way, because I have a lot of comments to cover. Members representing those communities have been voca...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill","courts tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-10/debates/CC3FC3F7-20F4-4923-918B-EBCBA40FE402/CourtsAndTribunalsBill#contribution-4A449EFA-909C-4C45-83DE-89F445926C70","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:057B9A79-862B-497C-88AA-0CC9AF3E9AF5","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-10","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill","safe_summary":"The right hon. Member has not been here for the entire debate, so I am afraid that I am not going to address his comm...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill","courts tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-10/debates/CC3FC3F7-20F4-4923-918B-EBCBA40FE402/CourtsAndTribunalsBill#contribution-057B9A79-862B-497C-88AA-0CC9AF3E9AF5","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:028CB597-9339-46AE-B79D-BC03C16E7DDF","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-03-10","title":"Courts and Tribunals Bill","safe_summary":"I will not respond to that point now, but I will say that there needs to be equality before the law irrespective of b...","topics":["courts and tribunals bill","courts tribunals bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts and Tribunals Bill"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-03.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-03-10/debates/CC3FC3F7-20F4-4923-918B-EBCBA40FE402/CourtsAndTribunalsBill#contribution-028CB597-9339-46AE-B79D-BC03C16E7DDF","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2266:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-02-24","title":"Opposition Day: Protections for children from online harms","safe_summary":"Opposition Day: Protections for children from online harms","topics":["young people","opposition day: protections for children from online harms","opposition day","protections children online harms"],"matching_terms":["Opposition Day: Protections for children from online harms","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2266,"division_number":434,"shard_href":"votes/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2266","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2263:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-02-23","title":"Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 3","safe_summary":"Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 3","topics":["industry and exports (financial assistance) bill committee: new clause 3","new clause 3","industry and exports (financial assistance) bill committee"],"matching_terms":["Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 3","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2263,"division_number":431,"shard_href":"votes/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2263","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2262:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-02-23","title":"Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 2","safe_summary":"Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 2","topics":["industry and exports (financial assistance) bill committee: new clause 2","new clause 2","industry and exports (financial assistance) bill committee"],"matching_terms":["Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 2","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2262,"division_number":430,"shard_href":"votes/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2262","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2261:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-02-23","title":"Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: Amendment 1","safe_summary":"Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: Amendment 1","topics":["industry and exports (financial assistance) bill committee: amendment 1","industry and exports (financial assistance) bill committee"],"matching_terms":["Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: Amendment 1","Recorded vote: No"],"vote":"No","division_id":2261,"division_number":429,"shard_href":"votes/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2261","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2255:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-02-11","title":"Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Maritime Activities) Order 2026","safe_summary":"Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Maritime Activities) Order 2026","topics":["draft greenhouse gas emissions trading scheme (amendment) (extension to maritime activities) order 2026"],"matching_terms":["Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Maritime Activities) Order 2026","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2255,"division_number":426,"shard_href":"votes/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2255","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:E19512D2-4A92-430A-95AA-799115205C75","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"I am glad that the right hon. Gentleman agrees that this is a matter of concern, although it is clearly not a concern...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-E19512D2-4A92-430A-95AA-799115205C75","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:DDA3386D-9E69-43C4-A950-C898D98A188D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"The right hon. Gentleman will know that I am all for being pragmatic and having dispute resolution, but, as I have sa...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-DDA3386D-9E69-43C4-A950-C898D98A188D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:D89D112B-90A0-4EF9-A0B9-E34C37701041","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"I want to be really clear that the data held by Courtsdesk is not an archive of criminal court case files. A number o...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-D89D112B-90A0-4EF9-A0B9-E34C37701041","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:B4A03748-1532-415C-90DC-BB2C80C1D770","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"Of course listing data is important, and of course it is important that it is accurate. By the way, it is also import...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-B4A03748-1532-415C-90DC-BB2C80C1D770","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:81E56017-1BC2-40CA-8517-C631D70238DA","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"My hon. Friend has asked a very good question. It is vital for people to know what goes on in our courts, and local r...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-81E56017-1BC2-40CA-8517-C631D70238DA","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:7E9808C8-A878-48AA-98A0-54A86A3E4E32","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"I am afraid that the bombast we have just heard is not just inaccurate but dangerous, because it suggests that there...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-7E9808C8-A878-48AA-98A0-54A86A3E4E32","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:53760DAB-FAFD-4667-A455-A0A76FEC44F7","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"The hon. Lady is right, in that the original agreement that was reached between Courtsdesk and the previous Governmen...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-53760DAB-FAFD-4667-A455-A0A76FEC44F7","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:4F851405-B936-4588-BC67-8BE554324918","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"Let me start by saying that this Government are committed to tackling grooming gangs, punishing offenders and protect...","topics":["young people","court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-4F851405-B936-4588-BC67-8BE554324918","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:336347D9-7EC3-4E64-ACD9-0B984CA64C2B","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"The answer to the hon. Gentleman’s question is that the report to the ICO has not yet been made. I raised the matter...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-336347D9-7EC3-4E64-ACD9-0B984CA64C2B","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:1F190D8B-A209-440E-8627-C1BDA161AEAC","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"I want to make it absolutely clear that accredited journalists continue—as they have throughout—to have access to cou...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-1F190D8B-A209-440E-8627-C1BDA161AEAC","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:153A396E-9EC0-412E-B9EE-988E8ADED4B4","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"I am committed, as are this Government, to greater transparency in our justice system. I am also committed to putting...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-153A396E-9EC0-412E-B9EE-988E8ADED4B4","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0C5AB5E2-141E-4496-8BDA-6022BE81D94D","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"I regard the data breach of the agreement as serious, and I referred it to the data officer at the MOJ. That is the c...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-0C5AB5E2-141E-4496-8BDA-6022BE81D94D","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"spoken:0877C83B-B43C-436A-9DBE-98FCA825E3F2","source":"spoken-contributions","date":"2026-02-10","title":"Court Reporting Data","safe_summary":"I share the hon. Lady’s concern regarding the victims, whom we so often fail to centre in our discussions in this Hou...","topics":["court reporting data"],"matching_terms":["Court Reporting Data"],"shard_href":"spoken-contributions/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-02-10/debates/037487A8-145D-44B0-AE56-37A1BBF5EE5E/CourtReportingData#contribution-0877C83B-B43C-436A-9DBE-98FCA825E3F2","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Hansard for exact wording and debate context.","text_completeness":"compact","truncated":true,"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2254:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-02-04","title":"Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) Order 2026","safe_summary":"Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) Order 2026","topics":["draft greenhouse gas emissions trading scheme (amendment) order 2026"],"matching_terms":["Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) Order 2026","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2254,"division_number":425,"shard_href":"votes/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2254","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"vote:2253:5204","source":"votes","date":"2026-02-03","title":"Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill: Second Reading","safe_summary":"Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill: Second Reading","topics":["young people","universal credit (removal of two child limit) bill: second reading","second reading","universal credit (removal of two child limit) bill"],"matching_terms":["Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill: Second Reading","Recorded vote: Aye"],"vote":"Aye","division_id":2253,"division_number":424,"shard_href":"votes/2026-02.json","official_url":"https://votes.parliament.uk/Votes/Commons/Division/2253","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open Commons Votes for motion context, result, and member vote.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"interests:latest","source":"interests","date":"2025-12-16","title":"Registered interests summary","safe_summary":"15 public registered interest entries across 5 categories.","topics":["registered interests","registered interests summary"],"matching_terms":["Registered interests summary"],"shard_href":"interests/latest.json","official_url":"https://members.parliament.uk/member/5204/registeredinterests","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open the Members Register for current full wording and updates.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"committee:810","source":"committees","date":"2025-06-26","title":"Courts (Remote Hearings) Bill","safe_summary":"Committee role: Courts (Remote Hearings) Bill (Commons).","topics":["courts (remote hearings) bill","courts remote hearings bill"],"matching_terms":["Courts (Remote Hearings) Bill"],"shard_href":"current-snapshot/index.json","official_url":"https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/810","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open the committee page for remit, membership, and latest updates.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]},{"id":"committee:758","source":"committees","date":"2025-01-15","title":"Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill","safe_summary":"Committee role: Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill (Commons).","topics":["terminally ill adults (end of life) bill"],"matching_terms":["Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill"],"shard_href":"current-snapshot/index.json","official_url":"https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/758","requires_official_source_before_quote":true,"official_source_use":"Open the committee page for remit, membership, and latest updates.","text_completeness":"compact","attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"]}],"shards":[],"attribution_keys":["uk_parliament"],"licence_keys":["uk_parliament"],"limitations":["Search records duplicate only compact retrieval metadata.","Use places/index.json for place-first Constituency Mention routing; source month shards remain the storage layer for full compact records.","Full Hansard text, written-answer text, EDM motion text, division context, register entries, and committee publications require official source deepening."]}